🔧 1. Applying SOLID in Layered Architecture
Most enterprise C# applications follow a layered architecture:
- Presentation Layer (UI/API)
- Business Layer (Services)
- Data Access Layer (Repositories)
- Infrastructure Layer (Logging, Email, etc.)
Each SOLID principle fits naturally into this structure:
| Layer | SOLID Application |
|---|---|
| UI/API | SRP, ISP |
| Services | OCP, LSP |
| Repositories | DIP |
| Cross-cutting (Logging, Caching) | DIP, SRP |
✅ Example:
Your Service Layer should have a single responsibility (e.g., OrderService shouldn't also send emails).
When adding a new discount type, you should extend the system, not modify existing discount logic (OCP).
If a new subclass of repository breaks existing behavior, you're likely violating LSP.
Services shouldn't depend on concrete SqlConnection or EmailSender, but on interfaces (DIP).
🧱 2. SOLID + Clean Architecture (aka Onion/Hexagonal Architecture)
SOLID is the backbone of Clean Architecture:
- SRP ensures each "layer" does one job (Controllers ≠ Services ≠ Repos).
- DIP is the core rule: inner layers (business logic) never depend on outer layers (UI, database).
- ISP ensures boundary interfaces (like IEmailSender, INotification) are lean and role-specific.
✅ Example:
// Domain Layer (Core) public interface IPaymentProcessor { void ProcessPayment(Order order); } // Infrastructure Layer public class StripePaymentProcessor : IPaymentProcessor { public void ProcessPayment(Order order) { /* logic */ } } // Application Layer public class OrderService { private readonly IPaymentProcessor _processor; public OrderService(IPaymentProcessor processor) { _processor = processor; } public void CompleteOrder(Order order) => _processor.ProcessPayment(order); }
Dependency flows inward, keeping your domain pure.
🧪 3. Unit Testing & Test-Driven Development (TDD)
SOLID makes unit testing effortless:
- SRP means fewer dependencies per class, easier mocks.
- DIP lets you swap real classes with fakes/mocks.
- ISP avoids bloated interfaces that make mocking harder.
✅ Testing Scenario:
public interface ILogger { void Log(string message); } public class OrderService { private readonly ILogger _logger; public OrderService(ILogger logger) { _logger = logger; } public void PlaceOrder() { _logger.Log("Order placed"); } }
Now you can write:
var mockLogger = new Mock<ILogger>(); var service = new OrderService(mockLogger.Object); service.PlaceOrder(); mockLogger.Verify(l => l.Log("Order placed"));
You didn’t have to touch any actual logger or database — thanks to DIP + SRP.
🛠 4. SOLID with Design Patterns
Design Patterns are often practical tools to implement SOLID.
| SOLID Principle | Common Design Patterns Used |
|---|---|
| SRP | Command, Builder |
| OCP | Strategy, Decorator |
| LSP | Template Method, State |
| ISP | Adapter, Proxy |
| DIP | Dependency Injection, Bridge |
🎯 Strategy Pattern for OCP:
interface ITaxCalculator { decimal Calculate(Order order); } class IndiaTax : ITaxCalculator { } class USATax : ITaxCalculator { } class InvoiceService { private readonly ITaxCalculator _calculator; public InvoiceService(ITaxCalculator calculator) { _calculator = calculator; } public decimal GenerateInvoice(Order order) { return _calculator.Calculate(order); } }
You can plug in new tax rules without touching InvoiceService — classic OCP.
⚙️ 5. SOLID in ASP.NET Core Middleware & Pipelines
- SRP: Middleware should do one task: LoggingMiddleware ≠ AuthenticationMiddleware.
- ISP: Each service should have role-specific interfaces (e.g., ICacheManager, ISessionManager).
- DIP: Use Dependency Injection to plug in loggers, services, DB contexts.
✅ Middleware Example:
public class LoggingMiddleware { private readonly RequestDelegate _next; private readonly ILogger<LoggingMiddleware> _logger; public LoggingMiddleware(RequestDelegate next, ILogger<LoggingMiddleware> logger) { _next = next; _logger = logger; } public async Task InvokeAsync(HttpContext context) { _logger.LogInformation("Handling request..."); await _next(context); _logger.LogInformation("Finished request."); } }
You’re depending on abstractions (ILogger) and doing one job.
📦 6. SOLID + Dependency Injection Containers
Using .NET’s built-in DI container, you’re already applying DIP:
services.AddScoped<IUserService, UserService>();
You can inject:
- Logger
- Repository
- Notification System
And easily replace them with stubs or mocks for testing.
📊 7. Refactoring Legacy Code with SOLID
If you're working in a codebase that violates SOLID:
Identify SRP violations – Break large classes into focused ones.
Extract interfaces – Apply DIP.
Avoid switch/case on types – Use polymorphism for OCP.
Replace deep inheritance – Consider composition if LSP is broken.
Split interfaces – to follow ISP.
✅ Refactor Example:
// Instead of public void Process(string type) { if (type == "csv") { /* CSV */ } else if (type == "xml") { /* XML */ } } // Use interface IFileProcessor { void Process(); } class CsvProcessor : IFileProcessor { } class XmlProcessor : IFileProcessor { }
🧠 8. Benefits in Large Teams & Long Projects
- Scalability: Add new features without touching old code (OCP).
- Collaboration: Multiple devs can work on separate classes/interfaces (SRP, ISP).
- Debugging: Smaller, isolated units are easier to test and fix (SRP, DIP).
- Maintainability: Code written today is easier to change next year.
✅ Final Thoughts
“SOLID is not a pattern, it’s a mindset.”
When followed diligently, SOLID:
- Prevents technical debt
- Enables rapid iteration
- Supports evolving business needs
- Ensures high-quality, robust, clean code
It’s not about writing more code — it’s about writing smarter, future-ready code.